Look up any NYC building’s records →
What the Warranty of Habitability Means
Under New York Real Property Law Section 235-b, every residential lease in New York State includes an implied warranty of habitability. This means your landlord is legally required to maintain your apartment in a safe, livable condition — regardless of what your lease says, regardless of whether you're rent-stabilized, and regardless of how long the problem has existed.
The warranty covers conditions that affect health and safety, including:
- No heat or hot water
- Mold or water damage
- Pest or rodent infestation
- Broken locks, windows, or doors
- Lead paint hazards
- Sewage or plumbing failures
- Structural damage
If your landlord fails to maintain these conditions, they are in breach of the warranty of habitability — and you have legal remedies.
What You Can Do
File an HPD complaint. Call 311 or go to nyc.gov/hpd to report a housing maintenance violation. HPD will send an inspector, issue a violation if conditions warrant, and create an official record. This is the most important first step — it documents the problem and creates legal pressure.
Withhold rent — carefully. In New York, tenants can withhold rent when a landlord breaches the warranty of habitability. But this is a legal strategy, not a simple one. If you withhold rent and the landlord files for eviction, you must raise the warranty of habitability as a defense in Housing Court — and you should have documentation of the problem and your attempts to get it fixed. Do not withhold rent without first getting legal advice.
File an HP Action. An HP (Housing Part) Action is a lawsuit you file against your landlord in Housing Court to force repairs. You do not need a lawyer to file. The court can order your landlord to make repairs within a specific timeframe, and failure to comply can result in fines. This is one of the most effective tools available to tenants.
Seek a rent reduction. If your apartment is rent-stabilized, you can file a complaint with DHCR for a reduction of services. If approved, your legal regulated rent is reduced until the conditions are corrected.
Sue for damages. In Housing Court, you can counterclaim for a rent abatement — a reduction in the rent you owe — based on the reduced value of your apartment during the period the conditions existed. Courts regularly award abatements of 10–50% of rent for serious conditions.
What Landlords Cannot Do
Your landlord cannot waive the warranty of habitability in a lease. Any clause in your lease that says you accept the apartment "as is" or waive your right to repairs is unenforceable under New York law.
Your landlord also cannot retaliate against you for asserting your rights. Filing an HPD complaint, filing an HP Action, or organizing with other tenants are all protected activities. If your landlord retaliates — raises your rent, fails to renew your lease, or harasses you — within one year of a protected complaint, the law presumes retaliation.
Can I Sue My Landlord for Breach of Warranty of Habitability?
Yes. You can sue your landlord in Housing Court for breach of the warranty of habitability and seek a rent abatement — a court-ordered reduction in rent reflecting the diminished value of your apartment during the period conditions existed. Courts regularly award abatements ranging from 10% to 50% of rent depending on the severity and duration of the conditions.
In cases of willful or egregious violations, you may also be able to seek additional damages. If your landlord's conduct amounts to harassment — deliberately allowing conditions to deteriorate to pressure you to leave — there are separate civil penalties of $2,000 to $10,000 per apartment under NYC Administrative Code §27-2115 (harassment itself is defined at §27-2004).
To file, you can either raise a warranty of habitability counterclaim in an existing eviction proceeding, or file a separate HP Action in Housing Court. Free legal help is available through the Universal Access to Counsel program — call 311 and ask for tenant legal services.
Can I Break My Lease Over Habitability Conditions?
In serious cases, yes. If your landlord has fundamentally failed to maintain habitable conditions — no heat for extended periods, severe mold, structural danger — New York courts have recognized a tenant's right to "constructive eviction": the conditions are so severe that you were effectively forced to leave.
To claim constructive eviction, you generally must: document the conditions thoroughly, give your landlord written notice and a reasonable opportunity to repair, and vacate the premises. If a court agrees the conditions constituted constructive eviction, you may be relieved of your remaining lease obligations and entitled to damages.
This is a significant legal step. Do not vacate your apartment without first consulting a tenant attorney — call 311 and ask for tenant legal services.
How to Build Your Case
Document everything:
- Photograph and date every condition
- Keep copies of all written communications with your landlord
- Save HPD inspection reports and violation notices
- Keep a written log of verbal complaints and your landlord's responses
Check your building's full HPD violation history on Weverit — a pattern of open violations across the building strengthens your individual case and tells you whether your landlord has a track record of ignoring repairs citywide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I withhold rent if my landlord won't make repairs in NYC? Technically yes, but it carries risk. If your landlord sues for eviction, you must raise the warranty of habitability as a defense in court with documentation. Get legal advice before withholding rent — call 311 and ask for tenant legal services.
What is an HP Action in NYC Housing Court? An HP Action is a court case you file to force your landlord to make repairs. You file it yourself at Housing Court. The court can order repairs and impose fines on landlords who don't comply.
Does the warranty of habitability apply to market-rate apartments? Yes. The warranty of habitability applies to all residential leases in New York State — rent-stabilized, market-rate, and subsidized.
How long does a landlord have to make repairs in NYC? HPD categorizes violations by severity: Class C (immediately hazardous) must be corrected within 24 hours; Class B (hazardous) within 30 days; Class A (non-hazardous) within 90 days.
Can my landlord put "as is" in my lease to avoid repairs? No. Any lease clause waiving the warranty of habitability is unenforceable under New York law.
Related NYC Housing Guides
- How to Check HPD Violations for Any NYC Building
- Your Landlord Can't Retaliate Against You — Here's How to Prove It
- How to Check If Your Apartment Is Rent-Stabilized in 2026
- NYC's Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants: What It Can Do for You
- NYC Heat and Hot Water Law: The Exact Temperatures Your Landlord Owes You
Sources: NY Real Property Law §235-b; NYC Administrative Code §27-2115; NYC HPD; NYC Housing Court; Legal Services NYC. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
