WeveritNYC Building Reports
Building report · Staten Island 10304 Independent · Tenant-side · No broker affiliations
Building report

521 Bay Street

Staten Island · 10304 | BBL 5004890001 | BIN 5013182
Generated 1 day ago (May 7, 2026)
B

Composite verdict

Solid building with some issues to address. B/76. Proceed with questions. There is 1 open hazardous violation(s) on file.

1
Open HPD
Class B
0
Open HPD
Class C
325
311 calls
past 12 months
Rent-stabilized
units
61
Crime score
(out of 100)
$1,516
ZIP median
rent
Zoned school
rating
1931
Year built
2 min
Closest subway
min walk
D
Noise grade
(311 complaints)
A
Walkable
errands grade
55 places
Amenities
nearby

521 Bay Street sits in Staten Island, ZIP 10304. The closest subway is Stapleton (SIR) (2-minute walk), served by the SIR line. Within an 800-meter walk you'll find 18 restaurants, 3 cafes, 20 groceries, and 6 pharmacies — a walkable-errands grade of A. Nearby public schools include Staten Island Community Charter School (grades K to 8), a 5-minute walk. Noise activity over the past 12 months is high noise activity — 92 noise complaints filed via 311, mostly residential noise. NYPD CompStat data places this precinct at a 61/100 safety score.

How many HPD violations does 521 Bay Street have?
As of May 6, 2026, 521 Bay Street has 10 open HPD violations: 1 Class B (hazardous) and 0 Class C (immediately hazardous). Source: NYC HPD.
Is 521 Bay Street rent-stabilized?
No — 521 Bay Street is fully market-rate. 4 residential units, none rent-stabilized. Source: DHCR / Taxbills.nyc.
Is 521 Bay Street in a safe neighborhood?
NYPD CompStat data scores this precinct at 61/100. Higher is safer. Source: NYC CompStat.
What's the closest subway to 521 Bay Street?
Stapleton (SIR) — a 2-minute walk (177m) from 521 Bay Street. Served by the SIR line.
How many 311 complaints have been filed near 521 Bay Street?
325 complaints have been filed via 311 within 150 meters of 521 Bay Street over the past 12 months. Source: NYC 311.
When was 521 Bay Street built?
Built in 1931. The building has 3 floors and 4 residential units. Source: NYC PLUTO.
Is 521 Bay Street subject to lead-paint regulations?
Yes — built in 1931, before NYC's 1960 lead-paint cutoff. Annual inspections are required for units with children under 6. Source: NYC Local Law 1.
HPD Violations
A
score 94/100
open 2total 10closed 8openClassA 1openClassB 1openClassC 0openClassI 0closedClassA 5closedClassB 0closedClassC 0closedClassI 3
  • Class B · 1 open · penalty 5 · (5/ea)
  • Class A · 1 open · penalty 1 · (1/ea)
HPD Complaints
heat 0mold 0other 0paint 0pests 0total 0bedbugs 0electric 0hotWater 0plumbing 0structural 0
311 / Quality of Life
drug 0rats 1noise 92other 199total 325trash 2parking 31drinking 0homeless 0construction 0
Noise (311 dedicated)
D
Crime
score 61/100
sex 0other 18violent 5property 14
Rent Stabilization
0 of 4 stabilized — building fully deregulated
0 recent evictions on file
Owner: ALEXANDER LEVIN (6-building portfolio)
ⓘ Email rent-info@nyshcr.org with your full address and apt# for free DHCR rent history
Bedbug History
Risk: clean · 0 infested last 3y · 2 filings on file
Most recent filing: Jul 17, 2025 · 0 units infested
Lead Paint Exposure
Source dataset wfmm-h6jk was retired by HPD; no public replacement on NYC OpenData. Workaround via wvxf-dwi5 NOVDescription filtering is deferred to a follow-up.
DOB Compliance
Complaints: 0 open / 3 total · Violations: 3 open / 3 total · 0 stop-work
Recent violations (3):
  • Jan 15, 2014 AEUHAZ1-FAIL TO CERTIFY CLASS 1 NONE "FAILURE TO CERTIFY CORRECTION ON IMMEDIATELY HAZARDOUS (CLASS 1) ECB VIOLATION"
  • Jan 15, 2014 AEUHAZ1-FAIL TO CERTIFY CLASS 1 NONE "FAILURE TO CERTIFY CORRECTION ON IMMEDIATELY HAZARDOUS (CLASS 1) ECB VIOLATION"
  • May 18, 2011 AEUHAZ1-FAIL TO CERTIFY CLASS 1 NONE "FAILURE TO CERTIFY CORRECTION ON IMMEDIATELY HAZARDOUS (CLASS 1) ECB VIOLATION"
Building (PLUTO)
Built 1931 (95 years old)
Building Class S9 (Class S9)
3 floors · 4 units
6,750 sqft building on 6,394 sqft lot
Owner: GOODSTUFF OF NEW YORK, INC.
Parking
5 garages within 800m · est. monthly: $150-280/mo
Top 3 closest:
  • SKY AUTO SPA INC 517 BAY ST · 25m · $150-280/mo
  • Degroat Air LLC 533 BAY ST · 42m · $150-280/mo
  • VANBRO MOTORS INC. 511 BAY ST · 46m · $150-280/mo
Schools
Closest: Staten Island Community Charter School · Elementary · K-8 · 5 min walk (411m) · District 84
Elementary: 5 · Middle: 4 · High: 4 · Total: 11 within 1.6km
Top elementary by walk:
  • Staten Island Community Charter School K-8 · 5 min
  • P.S. 65 The Academy of Innovative Learning Pre-K-5 · 7 min
ⓘ Data current as of 2019-2020 (NYC dataset historical)
Subway / Transit
1 station within 800m · 1 unique line · 2 min walk to closest
Lines: SIR
Top 1 closest:
  • Stapleton (SIR) 177m · 2 min walk
Neighborhood Amenities
A
atms 0cafes 3total 55fastFood 8pharmacies 6convenience 18restaurants 18supermarkets 2
Price vs ZIP Median
Median rent in ZIP 10304: $1,516/mo
Source: ACS 5-Year 2019-2023. Reflects existing leases, not current asking prices.
Affordability
Median household income in ZIP 10304: $71,506/yr ($5,959/mo)
Recommended max rent (30% rule): $1,788/mo
ZIP median rent: $1,516/mo
Affordable here: median rent fits within the 30% rule for the median household.
Source: ACS 5-Year 2019-2023.
Listing-Specific
This building report wasn't generated from a specific listing, so there's no per-unit pricing or fee breakdown to show. Use the search box on the home page with an address + listed rent to get a listing-specific verdict.
§ 06 — Latest news

Latest news from Weverit.

Tenant guides, law changes, and neighborhood reports — written in plain English, sourced from the same public records that power Weverit building reports.

NYC Brooklyn
MARKET BRIEF·May 9, 2026

Who NYC Rent Actually Works For

Three NYC households earning $85,000, $150,000, and $300,000. Same city, same rent prices, three different mathematical realities. The question of whether renting in New York is "possible" depends entirely on which of the three is being described.

Read article →
NYC Manhattan
TENANT BRIEF·May 8, 2026

The Sign in Your Lobby

A new sign appeared in the lobby of every NYC building with at least one rent-stabilized unit this winter. The text is unremarkable. The thing the sign does not say is the more interesting story.

Read article →
new york
INVESTIGATION·May 8, 2026

The 99-Unit Pattern

In the past two years, NYC developers have filed permits for more than 150 residential buildings with one thing in common: each has exactly 99 apartments. The number is not coincidence. It is a tax break threshold — and it is changing what gets built across the city.

Read article →
NYC street
MARKET BRIEF·May 8, 2026

NYC Is No Longer One Housing Market

On a Sunday in Bay Ridge, a detached house drew nine offers in four days. Forty minutes away in Downtown Brooklyn, a condo sat on the market for two months. Both are part of the same NYC housing market. Increasingly, they behave like different economies.

Read article →
NYC apartment building
METHODOLOGY·May 7, 2026

A 311 call is data. It is not necessarily evidence.

New Yorkers made roughly 3.4 million calls to 311 last year. Renters increasingly use that data to assess buildings and neighborhoods before signing. The patterns are real. They do not always mean what they look like.

Read article →
5 Brooklyn buildings. 166 violations. One Monday.
INVESTIGATION·May 6, 2026

5 Brooklyn buildings. 166 violations. One Monday.

On May 4, 2026, Brooklyn logged 9,717 of the city's 10,759 HPD violations — more than 90% of the citywide total. Five Brooklyn buildings alone produced 166 violations between them. Here's what that means for tenants in those addresses.

Read article →
Generated yesterday · Click ↻ to refresh data · Public records: NYC Open Data, MTA, JustFix WoW; neighborhood amenities © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL)